Wives and Husbands categories are unnecessary, Married Characters already encompasses them both. We had Mothers and Father categories deleted beforehand, and I suggest doing the same with these other two.
So I noticed we call the cuphead verse thread Cuphead (Verse). Probably due to Cuphead being a character himself. But we could probably just rename the verse “Cuphead: Don't Deal With The Devil”. Since that’s what the games actually called.
IIRC, we already discussed it before, Wikipedia already just calls it "Cuphead" when it comes to the series, for example, so just leaving it as just "Cuphead (Verse)" (Which was as such before) is better overall.
Awful reasoning, as there is actual no real reasoning. The only reason Phoenix Wrights anime was taken from the original page was because it was agreed to keep the Anime and Game separate in a thread rather than composited together. The anime should be perfectly fine to exist. Especially considering he has separate powers to the Game. Can this be undone please.
Saikou The Lewd King wrote:
The profile is from an adaptation. It's not different enough from the source material for a profile to be made. This was already discussed.
No. What was discussed was that the game and anime should be kept separate, as originally Phoenix page, had the anime and game profiles had been on the same page. A thread discussed it and said the anime wouldn’t be canon to the games.
On top of that. We had Staff actually saying the anime could have its own page.
“I mean it would be more simple to separate the anime and game profiles. Then, from them make a composite profile. So, it would be like 3 separate profiles.”
“Yeah, alternate canon profiles exist.”
The fact Phoenix has several different powers than in the game, even an episode that covers a case not done in the games should be plenty reason to let it have a page. There is no reason it shouldn’t exist, and it causes no harm, while having notably different powers and Physicality. This isn’t a carbon copy with every same ability and nothing new, Phoenix in the anime is Stronger, Tougher, has solved different cases, and has displayed several different powers all separate to the game. Plenty difference for it to get a page.
Even if two mediums are kept separate, if they're not different enough then they don't get their own profiles.
There is no reason it shouldn’t exist, and it causes no harm
Allowing profiles that are too similar can cause harm, by flooding the site with similar profiles.
Now, I'm not familiar enough with this verse to say whether they actually are too similar or not, I just wanted to respond to those points. Even if a character has some scenes which make them 8-C instead of 9-B, if 98% of the content between the mediums is the same, another profile probably isn't justified.
Anime Phoenix has different feats, extra story, and different powers. This isn’t just a matter of he is just physically stronger in this version. Several difference are made. It was even said in thread that it would be best to separate them into different pages rather than separate keys. As separate keys is what we almost did, but ended on the separate pages.
We don't allow similar counterparts. Agnaa is right.
Powers and abilities being different from another source isn't an excuse for having a profile for what's essentially a character with an already existent profile. The same applies to tier.
The adaptation needs to prove that it's different enough not only in the character's portrayal but overall storyline, like Dragon Ball GT which exists in a different timeline and has its own canon (we even have the author confirming this).
Phoenix Wright's anime profile doesn't fit this criteria AFAIK.
Anime Goku has very different stats and it serves an important purpose of powerscaling to other Toei profiles such as movies and GT. There's a reason why we don't have anime Vegeta, Krillin, Gohan, etc.
I agree that 2 counterparts that only differ in some of the stats shouldn't exist.
Yes it has been handled although I'm trying to get the " 's " removed from Tsubaki Chouji's Profile and Kahyouin Reika's Profile since I want them to be the same as all of my other Profile Blogs since I get irritated (And I still am getting irritated right now) when they're not the same as all of the other ones; a few examples are the ones below.
Why should the series be renamed just because the adaptation changed the name? Unless the profiles are for the anime only and don't use the original, I see no reason to use the name of the adaptation instead of that of the original.
However, as I mentioned in a comment in the blog, we really do need a content revision thread regarding the tiering of real world animals, as several of them have very exaggerated statistics due to accumulated kinetic energy while running full speed.
I request that Demons and Strangers name to be changed to Heresy as the author of the manga changed it and said that this was the true name of his universe. At beginning he was not sure what to name it as all he had was only a draft for just the early part of the manga, but now he think "Heresy" is more adequate for it.
On Pre-Genesis Archie Sonic's page in the optional equipment section, the Elasticity stone misspells "by" as "bt" in the description and in the Sword of Acorns' description the third sentence ("Sonic has been shown to carry up to fifty at one time with preparation, with each one on his person increasing his durability.") describes the Power Rings Sonic has carried at a time, and should be removed from the Sword of Acorns' description
Flowers (Knights of Pen & Paper) profile isn’t wrong, but it can be applied to any “Player” (No the, just player) in the game, and flowers is just one of the choosable “archetypes” like Alex in Minecraft
So it should be titled
“Player (Knights of Pen & Paper)”
Edit: this would also warrant a minor revision to the summary
I do not know whether or not the page should be renamed.
I talked to Zach. It looks there are multiple names in the game to choose in the game so I think it would better to change Flowers (Knights of Pen & Paper)'s profile name to "The Player (Knights of Pen & Paper)"
I suppose that makes sense, but Firey should have his name simplified, given its a slight change ending in -y to not spell out a genaric name (Fire). Same reason how Leafy was simplified, as it doesnt spell out the genaric name (Leaf).
The reasoning for Passive Statistics Reduction on Mechikabura's profile is that "His ability Darkness execution reduces the energy of his opponent by half at the start of the battle" but 'Darkness Execution' (or 'ダークネスエグゼキューション') is the name of his attack; his ability is '溢れ出る暗黒のエネルギー', which translates to 'Overflowing Dark Energy'.
We already have automatic protection that prevents non-staff members from moving pages, and our discussion moderators should be able to handle the responsibility. No change is necessary as far as I am concerned.
I can't open a thread about it tho (it doesn't have that button down below that says start a discussion) and Lego Marvel in general doesn't have a tag nor a verse page so how'd I even ask to check said revision?
@Tllmbrg You can click "explore", then "forum", then Content Revision and make a thread. Be sure to tag the relevant pages at the bottom, in this case Deadpool (Lego). As for who to ask, I suppose you can ask the creator of a page as well as a few staff member.
Also can someone unlock the Superman (Original) page? As I brought up in a CRT, destroying a skyscraper has been calculated as Low 7-B on our Reference for Common Feats page, plus the link is broken.