So, here’s how I see it. Both Sock and the puppet are going to have a hard time killing each other by their respective means, and because of this, it’s going to be a tough fight. There’s going to be very few things here that matter. What will matter is actual killing potential, stamina, and how likely they are to go down that path of murder.
So, what’s Puppet’s wincon? Use soul manipulation to absolutely screw up Sock to the point where he can’t fight back. The problem is that Puppet is unlikely to do that right away, especially since the only time he’s done it to my knowledge is to give life and not really destroy it. However, he could do something interesting and force Sock’s body into an immobile or otherwise harmless object and stuff it somewhere where it can’t get out, effectively incapping it. Is this likely? Not really. Is it an opening move? Heavens no, but it can do it.
What’s Sock’s wincon? Stab and cut and chip away at the puppet until it dies, or counteract the Puppet’s possession with his own, making it fight itself. The second one isn’t as likely, but the first one is, considering that all that Sock does is stab and cut.
Ultimately it’s a closer fight than one would think, but Sock’s freedom of movement via flight (though likely limited all the same), and his ability to go through walls to maintain cover likely makes him achieve his wincon more than the puppet can achieve its wincon.
With one final swing, with force put behind it, the puppets head came off completely. Sock blinked as it popped into the air, tumbling down onto the ground. With its head gone the Puppet’s actual body fell limp and collapsed onto the ground in a heap. Sock chuckled. “Well, haven’t done that in a while.”
He grabbed the Puppet’s disembodied head and grinned. “Now don’t look at me like that. You’re the one that couldn’t handle a fight.” He tucked it under his arm and began to walk out. “Jonathan! I know you’re working right now but look at what I found!”
Brought this up in a different thread, but I am pretty sure the Puppet can win here. Sock is, well should be Non-Corporeal via being a ghost. Also Puppet's soul manip can't really harm souls or spirits iirc, was only able to place the supposedly willing souls of dead kids into animatronics. Not sure it is combat applicable.
But the Puppet isn't harming them and is merely moving them into animatronics. Said spirits have possession so it is possible the souls did part of it themselves. It is never used in an attack or combative way.
Not necessarily, as characters that can move souls can't always touch or hold souls. The Puppet doesn't have Non-Physical Interaction as the ability doesn't seem to be physical in nature. also moving around something will not allow TP to harm Sock in any way.
My gosh. Okay, so, from what I understand, it’s not like the kids could leave the animatronics once the puppet could guide them inside, even if they wanted to leave them. They were left old and rotting, and the only way the spirits left the animatronics was because they got dismantled in FNaF 3 so I’m pretty sure the Puppet can force him to stay in the puppet.
Also did I ever say it would kill him? No. I said it would incapacitate him.
I know this thread has been commented in a long time(sorry im new here),and idk if my vote counts,but imma give my reason for the Puppet,The Puppet can soul manipulate,maybe that wouldn't work on Sock,but still,the Puppet can cause illusions,float,and either move really fast,or teleport,the Puppet has enhanced senses,and it was created as an security Puppet,to protect children(long story)It probably can fight,It can kill the player,and can just strike out if nowhere,also,I dont think a knife would do much to the Puppet,Im giving my vote for the Puppet