VS Battles Wiki

We have moved to an external forum hosted at https://vsbattles.com/

For information regarding the procedure that needs to be exactly followed to register there, please click here.

READ MORE

VS Battles Wiki
VS Battles Wiki

This page is dedicated to outlining the distinctions between DC Comics's different cosmologies. To summarize, the DC Universe has three dominant cosmologies characterized primarily (but not exclusively) by their authors: Grant Morrison, Scott Snyder, James Tynion IV, and Joshua Williamson; J.M. DeMatteis; and Neil Gaiman and Mike Carey.

Introduction

The above image is the "Multiversity Map" created by Grant Morrison to establish a cohesive representation of the various realms and layers of DC's complex cosmology. It brought a much-needed sense of cohesion and visualization to what was previously a very messy conglomerate of seemingly unrelated realms and cosmic beings.

Despite this valiant effort, the reality is much more complicated. DC Comics has been authored by hundreds of writers over its 80-year history, and several of the authors that have taken the helm regarding the cosmology have canonized very distinct and incompatible iterations of how these many realms and beings are described. However, the standard "composite DC" approach, fueled in part by DC Publishers asserting that all stories were canon, allowed character profiles to benefit from an amalgamation of these various cosmologies, resulting in tiers that were far-removed from their portrayals in any given storyline.

The following sections will define the main cosmologies of DC Comics, characterized primarily (but not exclusively) by their authorship. It is primarily intended to cover the most important realms and should not be taken as a completely exhaustive list of every minor realm that has ever appeared.

The division of DC's cosmology into these three categories is not exhaustive nor unbending, they are representative of "lines in the sand" based on approximations of the most prominent characterizations of the cosmology. For the purposes of tiering, these categories are the "rule of thumb," but cross-scaling into other material can occur when there is a clear evidentiary basis or narrative relevance.

Caveat #1: Dimensions

Within DC, the word Dimension has been used in a variety of ways to describe different things. It has been used to describe alternate universes, geometric and temporal dimensions (space and time), minor realms, and higher layers of reality. It is critical to consider the context and evidence available for each specific instance of the word, ideally within the same storyline.

Also, please note that even in the real world and in DC's cosmology, geometric spatial dimensions do not include time. The concept of 4D is depends entirely on context, often a shorthand method for writing "3 spatial + 1 time". Temporal dimensions will be discussed separately in this article.

Caveat #2: "Multiverse", "Universe", "World", and "Creation"

The terms above often have a variety of meanings. Context is key here. The term "multiverse" doesn't necessarily refer to the entire Multiversity Map, and "universe" doesn't necessarily refer to a single physics-based spacetime continuum.

This section will describe universes with a lowercase "u" when talking about individual universes within the Orrery, such as Earth-1 or Earth-2. DC's official stance is that each numbered "Earth" includes the universe itself + alternate timelines of that universe + alternate dimensions.[4] The phrase "DC Universe" will be used to refer to the entire franchise's setting.

Structure of a Single Universe

This section will describe the physical size and number of geometric spatial dimensions of a single universe. This information logically applies to each cosmology described below.

Size of a Single Universe

Universes in DC are far larger than the observable universe of our real world. While some stories from the different continuities treat a universe as infinite, this is contradicted by multiple stories about entities and items traveling "from the edge of the universe" or "across the entire universe" or "from every corner of the universe" not to mention the Source Wall which is the limit of the universe and as such, a universe is finite in size. The scans below are from 1991's Superman: The Man of Steel #115, which describes a more accurate universe size and can be used for every cosmology.

  • It should be noted that the statements of an infinite-sized universe are, as quoted above, contradicted by the mere fact that it has an edge and probably mean a single universe in DC Comics is immeasurably large rather than being truly infinite as suggested in the three scans above.

Geometric Dimensions

As for geometric spatial dimensions, refer to the scans below regarding the upper limit of individual universes. Remember, there are higher levels of spatial dimensions in DC's cosmology, but only this one specifically refers to the upper limit of spatial dimensions for an individual universe.

Temporal Dimensions

Finally, a single universe has one temporal dimension, giving it a linear timeline.

Tiering: Universal feats are between 3-A, unless the feat specifies an entire space-time continuum, the total destruction of a universe or something else (Low 2-C)

Crisis Cosmology

Throughout the 21st century, the DC Cosmology was established primarily by four authors: Grant Morrison, Scott Snyder, James Tynion IV, and Joshua Williamson. Collectively, these individuals were responsible for the development of concepts such as the Overvoid, the Monitors, Perpetua, the Dark Multiverse, the Collective Unconscious, etc. Their iteration of the cosmology draws heavily from principles preordained by previous authors; notably, the Crisis on Infinite Earths, the Monitor/Anti-Monitor, and the Endless.

It is worth mentioning that, while there were major differences between Williamson's work and that of Snyder/Tynion IV a year prior, most of these contradictions can be explained through Dark Crisis on Infinite Earths and Dark Crisis: The Deadly Green. Essentially, despite some discrepancies between these authors’ interpretations, in the grand scheme of things, their portrayal of DC’s setting is consistent enough to be considered a single cosmological continuity. It is worth noted that certain authors like Geoff Johns have also contributed to the expansion of the DC Universe, notably with the “Metaverse” as a means of illuminating the various changes taking place in the DC Universe.

Reality-Fiction Transcendence

Many of Morrison's works examine the relationship between reality and fiction, sometimes metaphorically and other times literally. Grant Morrison's idea is that all universes are interconnected together by comic books[10] that compile data from each reality of the local multiverse and are intimately linked to a simulation of the real world[11] with regard to Earth-Prime aka Earth-33, which dictates the reality of the other worlds of the Multiverse.[12] Earth-33 distincts from the other universes due to the "Fictive Membrane."[13] Unlike the other universes, Earth-33 lacks superheroes, except for a single 'superhero' who is a comic book itself, Ultra Comics.[14] When the Monitor race died following Final Crisis, beings called the Gentry came to invade the multiverse in the vacuum left behind, and the Gentry turned out to be from Earth-33,[15] suggesting that Earth-33 is within the standard DC Multiverse.

In Final Crisis: Superman Beyond #2, Cosmic Armor Superman felt the breath of an overreaching presence beyond his comprehension,[16] likely referring to the actual readers. The comic in question was in 3D, and one particular scene from those panels was Cosmic Armor Superman's hand reaching out towards us, which supports Morrison's claim when he said the Monitor Sphere is at the edge of the "art" and the mind of God. Such feats however are merely Breaking the Fourth Wall and do not necessarily demonstrate a transcendence of fiction.

Creation Origins

In the beginning, before the before, "the Creator" was everything. Nothing existed but his own quintessential perfection. As the creation of existence required space, the Creator contracted and withdrew into the perfect center of his own infinite circle (Ain Soph). He then entered the void with his power and name.

Manifesting himself in the void, the Great Darkness, as "the Voice", he created "the Light/Source" from the words: "Let there be light!". At first being only an invisible twinkle in the infinite immensity of the void, the Light grew. From the Light's otherness, the Great Darkness witnessed its first knowledge of self and screamed as much in pain as in relief before fleeing. This dual interaction caused a crack in the Source that birthed great energies from its being. With the birth of the Source from the dark, forces danced with each other like threads on destiny's loom, giving birth to the Lords of Chaos and the Lords of Order. The Source then generated super-celestial beings — the Hands — to shape these energies into bold new multiversal life systems.

One of these super-celestial beings was Perpetua. She made her Multiverse from the Source's energies and created her children — the Monitor, the Anti-Monitor, and the World Forger — to manage the different aspects of her new reality. At that point, Perpetua had fulfilled her duty and was supposed to die or move to create another Multiverse, but she defied her function. She then experimented on earthlings and martians, merging them into the Apex Predators. Her plan was to build an army to counter whatever the Source might send to force her to gave up her control over her Multiverse, which she attempted to transform into a viscous, predatory configuration of reality. Her sons learned of her treachery and alerted her kind of her doings, whose response was to send the Cosmic Raptor to seal Perpetua into the Source Wall and her Multiverse was restarted from the beginning of time.

Billions of years after Perpetua's defeat, Maltusian scientist Krona made a breakthrough and attempted to uncover the origins of creation. His manipulations unwittingly unleashed a Multiverse of infinite universes.

The Material Realms

Size of a Single Universe

Universes are much larger than the observable universe of our real world and, although some stories describe them as being infinitely expanding, this is contradicted by the presence of the Source Wall as "the edge of the universe" or "limit of the universe". As such, a universe is immeasurably large and is constantly expanding, but its size is finite.

Spatial Dimensions and Temporal Dimensions

As for the spatial and temporal dimensions, a universe is 4-D (3 spatial dimensions and 1 temporal dimension), although it should be noted that there are higher levels of spatial and temporal dimensions in this cosmology, but only this one specifically refers to the upper limit of spatial dimensions for an individual universe.

The Metaverse and Number of Universes

Metaverse

The Metaverse is what is known as Prime Earth, home to DC's main continuity. Normally, the universes of the multiverse do not influence each other, with the Metaverse being a single universe that the Multiverse reacts to and which forms around Superman's story. Since it's only one universe, manipulating or destroying the Metaverse does not in itself justify anything above 3-A or Low 2-C.

Number of Universes

There are a number of fifty-two universes. These universes are vibrating in the same space at different frequencies.[22] Here are Kendra Saunders' own words after studying the map of the multiverse: "We know of fifty-two, we believe it to be the set number."[23] She talks about the known universes of the "local" multiverse, although the exact number of universes is infinite, but this one specifically refers to the universes of the "local" multiverse.

Antimatter Universe

The Antimatter Universe is a singular realm located on the outskirts of creation.[27] Its creation and nature are bound to the Anti-Life Equation and beings made of positive matter cannot normally exist in this reality. Although its physical size is much larger than any positive matter universe, meaning that destroying all of the matter in it would be a much higher degree of 3-A, destroying it entirely would still only be a Low 2-C feat.

World Forge

The World Forge is a singular realm of dark matter located beneath the Orrery of Worlds. It is deeply connected to the hopes and fears of the people of the Orrery and has ties to Element X from which new universes are forged there. It is initiated by Alpheus, the World Forger, and his dragon, Barbatos.

Higher Spatial Dimensions

The DC Cosmology is repeatedly to have 11 dimensions and possibly more. Different numbers are given by different characters with differing amounts of cosmic knowledge.

Bleed Space and the Nature of the Fifth Dimension

First, note that the Fifth Dimension is not actually a physical realm and should not be considered a place that can be "mapped" because the Fifth Dimension exists and flows all around and between the realms of the multiverse, with the exception of the Sixth Dimension. It is placed here for ease of explanation.

Bleed Space

The Bleed, also called Bleedspace, is a dimension that can only be conventionally accessed by moving up through higher dimensions. It is the dimension that contains all brane universes, serving as the membrane keeping them apart and the "Bulk" encompassing them. The Bleed itself, despite being a dimensional space to lower-dimensional beings, is composed of Ultramenstruum, the essence of life according to Monitor Zillo Valla. The Bleed in several occasion is called the void since it lacks material composition meaning its “higher dimensional” nature crosses over all the dimensional space of the material plane and exists without it since it's been called both interdimensional and transdimensional.

Fifth Dimension

The Fifth Dimension, as far back as the 90s, has been defined as imagination and as a plane superseding the three geometric spatial dimensions, as well as superseding time. Scott Snyder carried forward this concept into comics and applied it to the cosmology as the blood of the multiverse, inhabited by Imaginary thought-constructs.[4]

Due to its existence outside of the Third and Fourth Dimension, the Fifth Dimension exists everywhere at once and beings from this level of reality perceive time on an atemporal way.

It is a very reasonable interpretation that the Bleed itself is in fact, or at least has a direct relationship with, the Fifth Dimension. The House of Heroes, rotating through the Bleed, was stated to rotate through the Fifth Dimension, and Mr. Mxyzptlk refers to imagination as the blood of the multiverse, a term which was later used by Rex Stegman to describe the Bleed. The Fifth Dimension itself is revealed to be made of a substance depicted like blood. In addition to the above points, the Monitors refer to Bleed as the substance of life itself, draining it out of creation and draining the life out of stories. Given that Mxyz uses "unimagination" and reduces the story back to sketches, everything seems to line up.

Finally, it is important to note that the Bleed clearly exists differently on different levels of reality. To the mortals living within normal universes, it is a higher-dimensional Bulk space. To the Fifth-Dimensional beings and presumably to the Sphere of the Gods, it exists as an energy flowing through creation. And to the Monitors, it exists as a tangible substance that can be handled and consumed like a drink, draining life out of the story of creation.

Orrery of Worlds and Local Multiverses

Orrery of Worlds

The Orrery of Worlds is the construct encompassing the local multiverse, originally created during the first contact of Monitor-Mind the Overvoid with the new creation within it. It also contains the Rock of Eternity and the House of Heroes which exist outside the universes. When Monitor-Mind The Overvoid found the new creation, it created a concept to contain creation, scabbing it over in divine metal.

Local Multiverses

Infinite Frontier was the first confirmation for this cosmology that the Pre-Crisis Multiverse had been saved after its reboot, but the Metaverse expanded on this concept further. Each reboot that changes the Metaverse and results in a new multiverse does not remove the previous iteration from existence. They all exist separately until the merging of both multiverses. As such, destroying or threatening a "multiverse" is heavily dependent on the context and era of the story.

Speed Force Wall

An energy field otherwise known to the inhabitants of the Orrery as the Speed of Light. It is described as the limit to matter on the main map of the multiverse by Grant Morrison. Thus, beyond this superluminal barrier, matter is converted into pure information.[64] This is important because outside this barrier starts a pattern of increasing levels of existence corresponding to less and less "realness" with archetypal realms inhabited by living ideas and thoughts.

It is important to note that the Speed Force Wall and the Speed Force are not necessarily the same thing, as the Speed Force Wall was revealed in Joshua Williamson's Flash series to be the barrier in which the Sage Force and the Strength Force were trapped and dormant.

Wonderworld

An enormous primal world orbiting the perimeter of the Orrery of Worlds at incredible velocities. It was deemed important enough by Morrison to devote an entire entry to the left side of the map of the multiverse. The very basic gist of Wonderworld is that it is the very perimeter of time and space with only the unknowable[72] of the metaphysical realms beyond it.

Bohm’s Implicate Order

The Implicate theory is a structuring of reality where there’s an unfolding/untold amount of reflection of the universes.[77] Which several in the story had been told to be higher dimensions(places) where there’s an endless hierarchy of worlds. A piece interconnected with the whole and the whole containing everything below.

Outside the edge of the Cosmos exists a plane that acts as a buffer zone between reality and the higher worlds beyond it from which reality is unfolded.[81]Which this plane is entirely a vast absence manifesting as light from which the worlds are continuously being created and destroyed.[82]Which the countless worlds that reflect upon each other from the Implicate above are manifested from this place[83](continuum from Limbo to Reality), an endless place of time and memory that seemingly produces endless reflection.[84]

The Metaphysical Realms

Due to their existence outside of the material realms, these realms are beyond our physics-based conception of the spatiotemporal multiverse. Many DC writers like to treat them collectively as "Platonic Realms" or as "Fictions".

Elemental Realms

The Green, the Red, the Grey, the Rot, the Clear, the Melt, the White, etc.

These realms are a bit more complicated to analyze because they have multiple layers to them. Often they simply refer to the realm relative to Earth, to a single planet, while other cases refer to the collective whole that encompasses the entire multiverse, but James Tynion's Justice League Dark run established that they are not places or realms, nor simply imagination, but lie between idea and reality where memory and consciousness of the Elemental concept exists outside of time and space.

Elemental Realms(Full Extent)

While the Elemental realms start in some sort of Limbo, in between things, outside of corporeal reality. The actual nature of these realms extends far beyond just being considered “below” the realms of beliefs and unreality.[95] Instead, they seemingly go on forever throughout the deeper layers(higher dimensions[96]) of Creation until they reach a[97] timeless[98] Void.[96]As such things like the Red at its fullest exist as an M-Field source from which is the source of all created existed as it exists in the timeless dark. In a space that is not space, in time that is not time, in a place beyond all-knowing, the Animal Master reconnects with the Red, and from their mind that exists everywhere and nowhere brought about all of existence again. Their thought became a template and their imagination were infinite touching all the worlds of real and unreal.[99] As mentioned previously the higher dimensions in which the Red exists[94] stretch to infinity[96] even connecting the Three Kingdoms.[100]Like the Implicate Theory which notions the idea of the higher realms affecting the lower ones as just dreams within dreams,[78]the lower realms are just figments of the higher worlds that can open access to them through imagination.[101]Accessing the anima mundi like what Buddy Baker had opened and connected his body and mind[102] to the conscious world of the Red, which is how he connected himself to the World Soul and became the very body of God.[103]

This could be said for the Green as well. Which in the layers of Green that Alec Holland went through transcended the human comprehension of three-dimensional view.[104]He became al that is by merging his consciousness with the Green when it touched all points of vegetable life[104] and became his very own oneness.[104]

Sphere of the Gods

The Sphere of the Gods is the overarching realm containing the godly and magical realms of the multiverse, and possesses an immaterial, metaphysical nature. It is home to the Archetypal Powers and Intelligences of the multiverse. The realm is stated to be made of literal possibility, and formed as an encompassing sphere around creation before creation had even finished forming. It is deeply tied to, and possibly indistinguishable from, the ideas and beliefs of mortals.

The very first thing to note comes from the map of the multiverse itself. Refers to Wonderworld, stated to orbit creation, which contextually refers to the Orrery. From that, it is quite clear that the Sphere of the Gods is not part of the material world and exists outside normal time and space. It is said to contain platonic, archetypal worlds inhabited by living ideas and to be fiction.

The Sphere of the Gods is the source of magic, the fundamental power of creation and belief, and the destruction of this energy would result in the destruction of the material world as a necessary consequence.

Continuing with the principle that the realms of the Godsphere are fictions, they are not real in the same way as the material world, they are ideas shaped by the beliefs of mortals. Therefore, events in the Sphere of the Gods operate on the basis of fiction and not normal causalities.

Nature of the Inhabitants of the Sphere of the Gods

Assuming Morrison's seemingly throwaway claim about platonic forms is taken seriously, there should be significant evidence that the inhabitants of the Sphere of the Gods adhere to platonic forms, although not all should adhere to such nature.

First, the very basics: they manifest in the material world as emanations of their true forms, called Godheads.

Next, existing as forms:

Finally, existing outside the material realm's visages of time and space, utterly transcends such mundane concepts.

Now, it is very important to note that even though the gods and deities were living ideas or platonic forms, they were all given forms by the beliefs of mortals worshiping them through the Collective Unconscious as mentioned below.

Collective Unconscious

The Collective Unconscious is the ideal "collective" form of mortal souls above the Sphere of the Gods from which all telepaths and greatest minds draw their abilities. It houses Hecate's personal realm, the Witch's Moon, a metaphor for the first mystery gazed upon by man. All gods and divine realms were born from the collective beliefs and imaginations of humanity. In this way, all the realms of the Sphere of the Gods are “fictions”.

In the relaunch of Justice League Dark, James Tynion IV and Ram V introduced a very old concept, that of beliefs defining creation from Mike Carey's Lucifer series, and applied it to cosmology. The idea is that the collective beliefs change reality and form gods and deities that are worshiped or feared by said believers through the Collective Unconscious. Metron explains this further in a tie-in to Death Metal, explaining that the multiverse is built on beliefs and that as mortals believe in gods they exist, who in turn believes in the Source it exists, although the Source exists beyond the Collective Unconscious.

Mortals and the Sphere of the Gods

Without special methods such as boom tubes or magical portals, the Sphere of the Gods can only be reached normally by mortals by transcending physicality, using the power of widespread belief to ascend into the Sphere of the Gods as true residents, seen with the Lord of Order (And presumably Chaos) below:

Mortals can enter the realms of the Sphere via magic portals, but once there they can only interact with a "shell" of the realm due to its extradimensional nature.[139]

Comic Book Limbo

Comic Book Limbo is the last outpost of existence proper before reaching the archetypal Monitor World and the Overvoid, where the forgotten characters of the DCU end up. It is not a permanent consignment - characters that were forgotten but are later reintroduced in stories leave Limbo and return to lower levels of reality. There are no stories in Limbo except for the Book of Infinite Pages, which contains every story of creation. There is no time in Limbo. "Time" in this context does not refer to the concept of time since the Monitor Sphere, above Limbo, has time. It goes one step further into nothingness, as Limbo is where matter and memory break down. Limbo exists separately from the Orrery, floating between it and the Thought Robot. It was stated that, when crashing out of the Orrery to end up in Limbo, the Ultima Thule was drifting into the void.

The statement "Music is over: We've run out of the Multiverse" doesn't mean that Limbo is outside of the whole creation, it only refers to Orrery of Worlds, because they used[36] the Ultima Thule for traveling between universes which is a trans-dimensional yacht powered by sound vibrations,[144] by altering its pitch and wavelength[144] it is possible to travel to other universes (because each universe has a different frequency), i.e. music being over means that Limbo is outside of all parallel universes and the Orrery.

Monitor Sphere

The Monitor Sphere is an archetypal world[145] and home to Nil, the world of the Monitor race. While the mystery of the Orrery and the Thought Robot caused Monitor-Mind to invent stories to accompany it, the Monitor Sphere took shape outside of the Sphere of the Gods. Remember from the previous section how going from the multiverse to Comic Book Limbo required crossing the void. This is reflected in statements that Nil is part of the void[36] and that Monitor nanotechnology is coming from the void to attack Limbo.[16] As a quick aside, Monitor tech operates in concept space and can be used to construct realities. Monitor ships that can adjust their scale to be gigantic within the Multiverse and to the size of cities within Limbo, were regarded as infinitesimal to the Monitors World.[16]

The beings of this world are notable for being the only ones capable of bottling and consuming Bleed as a tangible substance.[146] This is extremely significant: we know that, from the perspective of lower mortal "germs", Bleed is the Bulk Space enclosing the worlds of the Orrery. We know also that Bleed is the substance of Life, from Zillo Valla. In metafictional terms, it is what gives life to the stories of the Orrery. The Monitors are capable of extracting it as a tangible substance, draining creation dry. This interpretation is confirmed by Morrison himself: what Mandrakk is doing by extracting Bleed as a consumable is sucking the life out of the story. See the scans below:

You may have noticed a pattern by now of elevating levels of existence[149] corresponding to less and less "real-ness" as we would think of it in real life. Beings in the Orrery are made of matter and operate within physical space and time. Beings in the Sphere of the Gods are pure idea and operate within metaphysical story. Beings in Limbo lack even story. And Nil takes this pattern to the next level, as far as reasonably possible before achieving the pure absolute Nothingness/Oneness of the Overvoid. The world of the Monitors is the Blank, the Nil, the Gone, the edge of everything where form and meaning surrender to the nothingness of the Overvoid. Its inhabitants have 5555 terms for "nothing", and presumably a similar number of types of nothing.

Concepts like space, time and scale are more meaningful, profound, with "time" in the Monitor Sphere referring to the clockwork pattern in the sky. Time in Nil seems to function as a temporal dimension, because when it entered the Monitor Sphere, it form "beginnings" and "ends".

Finally, although the writing quality is subjective, the Unexpected series did not make Nil just a normal place people can travel to. It was accessed because a unique Nth Metal isotope resonated with Ultramenstruum to create a hole in reality, sending the team outside the multiverse.

The Dark Multiverse and the Other Place

Dark Multiverse

A vast subconscious realm of dark matter upon which floats the Multiverse.[23] It's the unintended side effect of the process of creating new worlds, coupled with the treachery of Barbatos. It consists of infinite worlds of nightmare, similar to the infinite timelines of the main Multiverse has. It is directly stated that Perpetua's original Creation had nothing to do with the formation of the Dark Multiverse. Some realms such as the Dreaming and the Phantom Zone have strong connections to the Dark Multiverse.

The Other Place

An empty void of space inhabited by the Otherkind. Long since Hecate imprisonned the Upside-Down Man here since the dawn of the multiverse, he infected this place with his reality. It is the source of all dark magic that Hecate took a piece of and gave to humanity to "curse" them. Although in the 2018 relaunch of Justice League Dark, James Tynion IV presented the Great Darkness as the dark opposite to the Sphere of the Gods,[159] connected to the Dark Multiverse, this notion was later retconned by Joshua Williamson.

Source Wall and the Totality of Creation

The Divine Continuum and Hypertime

Divine Continuum

Although certain aspects of cosmology such as the location of Hypertime or the nature of a "wider" DC Multiverse have been difficult to evaluate, Geoff Johns partly answered this question in Flashpoint Beyond with an entirely new concept, that of the Divine Continuum as defined by Dr. Bonnie Baxter, it represents Existence itself, formed by two aspects of reality. The first half is Space, which is physically represented by the "wider" DC Multiverse; the second half is Time which is represented by the abstraction known as Hypertime.

To fully avoid confusion about this concept, it is necessary to discard the idea of the Omniverse, or the idea of the multiverse becoming its own web of multiverses from the end of Death Metal,[162] as this was proven to be false according to Lex Luthor who, during his time with the Totality, discovered the truths and lies of the multiverse.[163] Refers to the Local Multiverses section, as the concept of a wider DC Multiverse has always existed, all iterations of the multiverse still exist but separately from each other, which now refers to the space aspect of the Divine Continuum.

The Space aspect has always been represented by the various iterations of the multiverse and is split into the Multiverse, the Metaverse, the Sphere of the Gods, and the Dark Multiverse. Although neither Comic Book Limbo nor Monitor Sphere have been mentioned as being part of the space aspect, it is not a stretch to assume that they do since the Dark Multiverse, which encompasses them, is part of the space aspect. Due to the many Crises that the multiverse has faced as a consequence of various attacks, the Space aspect has always been changing, being shaping around a single universe referred to as the "Metaverse", until the combined efforts of the Flash Family and Dr. Light merged the multiverses.

Hypertime

Now we come to Hypertime. It can be said that there are two lenses to view this concept through: a basic, functional level, and a complete, metafictional level. That is not to say that there are two Hypertimes or that one is more correct than the other, but that most stories referencing it will simply depict the first for ease of explanation.

The basis: Hypertime, as defined by the Fuginauts, is an abstraction, a temporal nexus allowing access to all timelines formed across existence. It is distinct from the Timestream in that, while the timelines all exist in the Timestream, they they burrow[167] through Hypertime. The Hypertime abstraction has a manifestation called the Branefold Interior, where the Fuginauts exist not only to maintain boundaries between timelines but also between the Multiverse and Dark Multiverse.

Basically, Hypertime is a three-dimensional, time-based concept created by Grant Morrison and Mark Waid to allow all parts of DC's published stories to interact with each other. Morrison sometimes uses geometry as a metaphor to discuss Hypertime, using concepts such as "plane time" and "cube time". This is shown in The Return of Bruce Wayne and expanded upon in an interview, treating it as a three-dimensional concept, its basis being the "time point" containing all possibilities.

By simple geometry, the time point extent to create the "line time" or "line space a"[174] representing the linear timeline from beginning to end. Time also extends laterally, so there is the "plane time" or "space b",[174] an immense cosmic loom of converging and separating line times. The perpendicular of plane time is "cube time"[174] which views the inhabitants of the Orrery from a higher-dimensional perspective.

Sixth Dimension

The Sixth Dimension is a plane of existence where the prior version of the multiverse was designed and set in motion by Perpetua. It is distinct from the Monitor Sphere in that although the Monitor Sphere exists at the edge of things, the Sixth Dimension is the highest plane of existence. It is stated to be beyond time and imagination and is at the top of everything on the map of the multiverse. The Sixth Dimension can only be reached by non-Monitors after the Source Wall has been breached, and is completely beyond Mxyzptlk's perception despite existing outside of time.

Despite this, the Sixth Dimension does not appear to completely transcend time since the Sixth Dimension is spoken of in a timeline of 20 billion years and when Superman fights in the Sixth Dimension, his speed is spoken of in physical terms, saying that it will take hours for the light to catch up, months for the sound.

Scott Snyder clarified in an interview[176] that the Sixth Dimension is not outside the Source Wall and that the Sixth Dimension is a spherical layer that envelops the entire multiverse, a "control room" where quintessential beings oversee the development and progression of the multiverse. For this reason, their stature is naturally higher than all other entities inhabiting the multiverse.

Promethean Galaxy and the Source Wall

While not a literal galaxy, the Promethean Galaxy is a realm as old as creation and farthest finite frontier of reality where the Source Wall is located. The Source Wall is the limit to thought[57] and the protective shell around the Multiverse, closing it off from the Greater Omniverse. In all directions from any universe within the Multiverse, the wall is the final point, separating all of creation from the Overvoid. In Countdown, which contradicted Final Crisis in many ways it was said that the Source Wall separates universes.[177] However, this does not fit with the rest of Morrison's works.

Nil did not have the Source Wall around it during Final Crisis, this is because the Source Wall was destroyed[179] in Death of the New Gods, which was a lead-in comic to Final Crisis. Grant Morrison affirmed[180] that elements of Final Crisis were intentionally written to match the events of DotNG in this interview:

Tier:

Characters existing in, or affecting, the Source Wall shouldn't be 1-C or Tier 1 as the wall exists on every level of reality. A Tier 4 being that portals themselves to the outer edge of their reality to the Promethean Galaxy is still a Tier 4 being, and they are only experiencing the Promethean Galaxy on a lower-dimensional level.

Greater Omniverse/Infinite

First of all, it should be noted that the word "Omniverse" has been used a lot in recent years and that while the multiverse has been referred to as the Omniverse in some stories, it has nothing to do with the Greater Omniverse mentioned in Scott Snyder's Justice League run.

Beyond the Source Wall and Creation, there are an infinite number of Multiverses that rise and fall across the Overvoid, made by various creators such as The Hands using the energy entrusted to them by The Source. Although the idea of a multitude of rising and falling creations primarily came from Mike Carey's Lucifer series, Scott Snyder expanded on this concept further.

Part of the idea made by Snyder is that, as described by Alpheus, when a multiverse breaks apart before its final evolution, it is sent back to the banks of creation where it was created by super-celestial beings like Perpetua. This is echoed by Alpheus who stated that main Multiverse was flying through the void to an unknown destination, awaiting the final judgement,[184] and by Perpetua who stated that she would come to the end of the void to eliminate her kind, The Hands, meaning that they exist in the Overvoid.

The 2024's Flash series provided new insights into DC Comics Cosmology, introducing an unknown conceptual place within the Speed Force called the "Garden of Shadows" or "Gallery of Moments", beyond the Source Wall, beneath everything, deeper than space and time and where though and expression are one. From there, Wally West interacted through the comic book panel in a place far beyond and below time and space.

The Deep Change/Speedforce

The Deep Change is a universal energy of change that hits all[186] parts[187] of time and space[188]. It exists in a place of no place[189] where it dreamed of everything such as Time,[190]which is all permeating and everything are emanation[190] of it. Reality, itself, is composed of endless emanation of the lower planes.[190]It is possible to assume that it was birth by the Source since the Speedforce is a part of the totality that was created by the Source itself. The Deep Change after awaking transformed the Arc Angles into a new wandering Stillness wandering about from the Curve Corner. Which the Arc Angles being the first emanation of the Deep Change gave Wally West, a realm of their own.[190]It was[191] mentioned[35] several[191] times[189] that the Deep Change and the Speedforce are one and the same thing, perhaps the Speedforce is a direct manifestation of the Deep Change.

Unseen Council

The name used by Scott Snyder in an interview to describe a hierarchy of unseen beings that eventually reach The Source. According to Metron, beings of the Greater Omniverse are several rungs above those of the Sphere of the Gods or the Monitor Sphere in what he referred to as the cosmic ladder, and are qualitatively superior to the Divine Continuum. Notable individuals in this hierarchy are The Hands who rules the many multiverses in the Greater Omniverse, Chronicler who records the history of any dying multiverses, and the Cosmic Raptor who sealed Perpetua in the Source Wall.

Source/Overvoid/Light

Although commonly associated with different parts of the DC cosmology, these various entities have been suggested or outright stated over the years as sharing an equal nature and stature, all giving rise to, encompassing and sustaining the Greater Omniverse, and existing as completely transcendent to the Divine Continuum and, by extension, beyond all space and time. Despite sometimes ambiguous due to the different approaches of different authors, many have adhered to the idea that these three overarching deities are associated with the Godhead, being either aspects or manifestations of The Presence.

Great Darkness/Primordial Darkness

In the prelude to Dark Crisis on Infinite Earths, Joshua Williamson reintroduced an old concept, that of the Great Darkness introduced in Allen Moore's Swamp Thing series, and combined it with the Overvoid from Grant Morrison's Multiversity using the origins of creation related in Marv Wolfman's Crisis on Infinite Earths. Joshua Williamson specifically refers to key passages from these stories and adjusted them to what Grant Morrison and Scott Snyder have architected over the years for DC continuity.

Those who have read the issues 49 and 50 of Alan Moore's Swamp Thing series will remember the Great Darkness as the opposite of God's light and existed before the first light came into existence. Translating this into the modern cosmology, the Great Darkness existed before the Overvoid which Joshua Williamson seemingly associated with the Light of Creation or God's light, brought into existence within the Primordial Darkness when God said: "Let there be light!"

The Great Darkness precedes, encompasses, and surpasses Monitor-Mind The Overvoid, The Source, The Light of Creation, and is tied to the Shadowlands, the place where God sent the Primordial Darkness when he brought forth the light, and to which individuals like Alan Scott and Obsidian have ties. The Great Darkness has also various aspects and avatars like Darkseid, Empty Hand, Upside-Down Man, Trigon, and Lucifer, but it is neither an evil nor a nihilistic force. It just sits in the black for eternity, watching everything as a flicker of light waiting to be extinguished by itself.

Creator/Presence/God

Despite the ambiguity made by the different approaches of various authors over the years, most of them have adhered to the notion of a supreme, underlying God standing utterly devoid of definition and beyond opposites, and manifesting itself in many distinct yet equal figures: Monitor-Mind The Overvoid, The Source, The Light of Creation. One God, all three points of view being aspects or manifestations of the same whole, standing as transcendental to the Greater Omniverse as these entities are. The nature of this entity is non-dual, beyond the war of light and darkness, and breathed everything into existence.[214] The Voice who created The Word when he first spoken, commanding The Light through it, is an aspect of God.[215][216][217][218]The Presence is pure divinity that hides the perfection of the true face of God.[219]Which in several[220] examples[221] is beyond the Great Darkness as well as the Source.[222]The Source and the Great Darkness as mentioned previously is preceded by the Presence, but also he contains it since the Void[223](Darkness) is simply his mind,[224]and the Source is the energy that he manifests as he is everywhere[225] and[226] everything[227].

Tiering

  • Universal feats range from 3-A to Low 2-C whether the feat involves an entire space-time continuum or simply involves all matter in the universe.
  • Multiversal feats really depend on the context given in the comics and range from 2-C to 2-A, whether the feat involves all fifty-two universes of the Orrery or infinite universes or timelines.
    • Feats of creation or destruction of the level of the Antimatter Universe are higher degree of Low 2-C than regular positive matter universes.
  • Orrery of Worlds - High 1-C: The multiversal superstructure of fifty-two brane universes with eleven dimensions based on M-Theory and Brane Cosmology of which four dimensions constitute any single universe within the 11-D "Bulk" or "Bleed". It's possible that the Orrery of Worlds is not limited to eleven dimensions and that there may be higher dimensions, but since their locations in the cosmology have not been decided, it is difficult to locate them correctly.
    • Plicate and Implicate Order - High 1-B: The interconnection of the universes are pieces that contain the whole. In a series of recessions of worlds being beyond the previous as seen as “dreams” within a larger dream that stretches endlessly.
      • Totality of the Material Plane - Low 1-A: At the very edge of the Cosmos lies limitless time and space. Which itself contains all the levels represented by the hierarchies of the world in the plicate order which are emanated from the higher worlds of the Implicate.
  • Sphere of the Gods - 1-A: The magical sphere surrounding the Orrery of Worlds inhabited by gods, demigods, angels, demons or any magical being worshiped by mortals. It is located outside the Orrery's superluminal barrier, where matter is converted into pure information and thus outside of corporeal reality, having archetypal, platonic, and higher vibratory worlds than those of the Orrery of Worlds. It has close ties to beliefs which shaped every realm or entity in the Sphere of the Gods through the Collective Unconscious, and is one of the Connective Energy born of The Source. At the crest of the Sphere of the Gods is the Collective Unconscious, which manifests divinity through belief and is inhabited by Hecate. It is also one of the Connective Energy.
    • Dreaming/Collective Unconscious(Full Extent) - 1-A+: The higher-end realms of the Sphere of the Gods have a hierarchy that seemingly is endlessly and reaches every part of Creation such as the Dreaming, the Red, and the Green which touches every plane and level of existence.
  • Comic Book Limbo - 1-A: The last outpost of existence proper before reaching the Monitor Sphere and is the dumping ground for all the forgotten of the Orrery of Worlds. Despite being positioned higher on the Map of the Multiverse, Comic Book Limbo has shown no signs of quantitative superiority over the Sphere of the Gods.
  • Monitor Sphere - 1-A: The archetypal Monitor World inhabited by the Monitors of Nil, a primal and fundamental world where space, time, scale are more profound and meaningful. It exists at the edge of things, on a higher plane of existence than Comic Book Limbo, and when Mandrakk fell from there, he fell into the Overvoid and landed in the Dark Multiverse. From there, Mar Novu peered beyond the void, into the Greater Omniverse, to observe the neighboring Multiverses.
  • Dark Multiverse - 1-A: The sea of the unconscious upon which floats the Multiverse, located beneath Creation, and containing infinite universes based on the hopes and fears of all living beings in the Orrery of Worlds above. At the center of the Dark Multiverse lies the Forge of Worlds, a place of pure possibility and dark matter, where universes are forged and returned. On the border surrounding the Dark Multiverse is the Otherworld inhabited by the Otherkinds and the Upside-Down Man. It is the dark yet much larger equivalent of the Sphere of the Gods.
  • Divine Continuum - 1-A+: The hypothetical model of Existence which is represented by all space and time. (i.e. Omniverse and Hypertime) The Space aspect of the Divine Continuum (Omniverse) is divided by the Orrery of Worlds (and infinite Multiverses), Metaverse (Earth Prime), Sphere of the Gods, Dark Multiverse. The Time aspect of the Divine Continuum (Hypertime) is divided into Limbo and Vanishing Point. It is very likely that higher layers of existence from the SpectraVerse are contained within it, though some layers are outside of Creation.
    • Feats of creation or destruction involving Hypertime timelines should be considered 2-A depending on the context.
  • Fifth Dimension - 1-A+: The "energy" that flows between realms is Imagination and is inhabited by imaginary-thought constructs which are considered as "imaginary friends" or "guardian angels". It exists everywhere at once, outside of Time and Hypertime. It has no specific place in the cosmology.
  • Sixth Dimension - 1-A+: The highest plane of existence and the final realm, between the Monitor Sphere and the Source Wall within the model of the DC Comics Cosmology. It is a realm of the impossible for things beyond the imagination of most living beings and is outside of time and understanding, in which lower beings could not experience without higher intervention. It distinct itself from the Monitor Sphere in that, although the Monitor Sphere exists at the edge of things, the Sixth Dimension is the highest plane of existence where the Multiverse was designed and set to motion by Perpetua.
  • Greater Omniverse/Infinite - High 1-A: Outside the Source Wall lies the "Infinite" or "Greater Omniverse" located within the Overvoid outside and beyond Creation, having conceptual places beyond space and time and where thought and expression are one. It is where infinite Multiverses are created and judged by The Hands, and where the Deep Change operates, the Speed Force being an enmanation of the Deep Change and one of the Connective Energy born of The Source, which itself contains the Gallery of Moments/Garden of Shadows.
    • Unseen Council - High 1-A: The hierarchy of unseen beings that eventually reach The Source. They reside outside the Source Wall, in the Overvoid where they oversee the infinite Multiverses within the Greater Omniverse under oath to The Source. They are positioned far higher in the hierarchy than any god within the Sphere of the Gods or the Monitor Sphere, and beings like Perpetua can tear pieces from the Overvoid.
    • Deep Change/Speedforce - High 1-A: This place of no place transcends the entirety of the Multiverse and its emanative hierarchy as the whole of that is simply a dream from it and only exists due to it.
  • Source/Overvoid/Light - High 1-A: The three primordial aspects of The Presence that gave rise to, encompasses and sustains everything in the Greater Omniverse. The Source is the great energy of creation associated with Life and Creation from which any of the Connective Energy, which includes the Speed Force, were born and used by The Hands to shape Multiversal Systems within the Void. The Overvoid/Light of Creation, sometimes associated with Heaven, Angels and Creation, is the conscious living void and canvas of Creation outside of time and space and between the Multiverse and the Great Darkness.
  • Great Darkness/Primordial Darkness - High 1-A+ (Type 2): The Primordial Darkness preceding life, death, matter and magic and of which nothing and everything were the same thing. The Source and The Light of Creation were born of the Primordial Darkness which encompasses all.
  • Creator/Presence/God - 0: The non-dual and immutable God who breathed everything into existence, standing utterly beyond the war of Light and Darkness, and all opposites, and is in a place where there is no time or space, being synonymous with the Void. It manifest itself in three distinct yet equal figures: Monitor-Mind The Overvoid, The Source, The Light of Creation. The Voice who created The Word when he first spoken, commanding The Light through it, is an aspect of God.

J.M. DeMatteis' Cosmology

DeMatteis' approach on the DC cosmology was heavily influenced by his spiritual beliefs and world view based on Hinduism and other religious concepts. He has stated that this belief influences almost all of his work.

Creation Origins

The Divine Presence dreamed all of Creation, and was formed in nothingness and will eventually return to it again.[239] In the act of creation, duality was born, then Chaos and Order created an explosion not of power but of love that created a sea of love from which emerged whole worlds and universes.

God, Soul, Creation as Dream

DeMatteis' cosmology incorporates ideas from the philosophy of an Indian spiritualist named Meher Baba, who proposed the idea that God dreamed our Universe, He described the observable world as illusory, and presented the idea that the Universe is imagination. He taught that God alone exists, and each soul is God passing through imagination in order to realize its own divinity. He likens these individual souls to bubbles in an ocean of infinite size.

In DeMatteis' works, he uses the same concept for his cosmology, God dreamed the entire Universe and all stars, planets and souls are part of its imagination. The Universe exists on many different levels with the Material level being the most obvious. There are limitless planes of existence deeper and truer levels of the Universe. "Planes" or "Levels" of the Universe is referring to the fact that in DeMatteis's cosmology, reality is just a dream/illusion. Everything is just an illusion that separates souls to the oneness of God.[242] For example, it was stated that Heaven is a deeper and truer realm than the normal universe.

Cycle of Creation and the World Ages

DeMatteis consistently depicts Creation with cycles based on the Hindu concept of Yugas[239] representing in Hinduism four ages of the life of the world. These cycles are the Satya Yuga, the Golden Age from which everything existed in perfect harmony in spiritual purity,[247] it's the purest state of the dream before it was layered over with nightmares.[247] Treta Yuga and Dvapara Yuga came after[247] the Golden Age and were the ages of the Atlanteans and the Lemurians. Kali Yuga is the last and the worst of the four ages representing the modern era. It's sometimes called a delusion. If the Golden Age is the dream in its purest form, then the world during Kali Yuga strays further away from God and is buried under layers of nightmares.

The idea of the fall of Creation back into nothingness at the end of a Yuga cycle is often referred to as[239] the Mahapralaya or the Sea of Brahma. Like the concept of the Yugas, there are four types of Mahapralaya/Pralaya. The Void from which all things emerged was revealed to be Pralaya who predates all things in existence, even the Creator himself,[248] an aspect of God, and is referred as God's Unconscious.

The Material Realms

Number of Universes

There are an infinite number of universes, each decision forms new universes all the time. There is a Crown of Chakra, the energy doorway that links individuals to everything and beyond it, there's the Quantum Web, the universe's true form that connects everyone.[249]

Tiering: There are infinite universes and parallel dimensions, each decision forms new universes all the time. The material plane is just the debased level of Creation called the Gross Plane. Everything in Creation is a result of a dream in a dream. The material plane encompasses all the simplest levels driven by the five senses. Due to its relation to being just a dream in the higher planes, it would warrant a 1-A rating, and because there's limitless potential and possibility. Its hierarchical positing pivots a hierarchy of R>F transcendence thus the “+” modifier can be used. So any Multiversal feat of any degree affecting the material plane is 1-A and total destruction is 1-A+.

The Metaphysical Realms

The higher planes of existence are truer and deeper levels of God's dream than the Material Universe. Each plane are closer to God's oneness. Heaven, for instance, exists far beyond the level of the Material Universe, but there are more realms beyond it and each deep realm is more close to the Divine Presence.

Collective Unconscious

In DeMatteis' storylines, the Collective Unconscious is the universal consciousness, basically the collective form of mortal souls, split into individual souls upon emanating down to the Material Universe. It's a cosmic sea of symbols and archetypes, dreams and ideas, made manifest. It's a realm of energy and imagination where emotions are colors and thoughts have textures.[252]

Heaven

In DeMatteis' storylines, Heaven is a higher plane of existence. It is more deep, more true and closer to the Presence than the Material Universe.[244] For example, Indra's Fourth Heaven is a place that is not a place, but transcends place, referring to a higher dimensional realm. Heaven contains an infinite number of universes tailored to the beliefs of its inhabitants. These various heavens are said to be a state of mind rather than true places, with different planes beyond the conventional Heavens meant to give comfort to the souls of the defuncts.[254]

Tiering: The higher planes of existence have "days" which transcend day and "places" which transcend place, each of them being truer and deeper then the Material World, giving them a meta-transcendence nature and a superior level of existence. This means any higher plane including Heaven, Hell, and the Collective Unconscious would be High 1-A. Since like the Material World, the Metaphysical planes are layered as each Heaven is simply a projection of the mind, and there are things beyond conventional Heaven where Souls turn into pure energy called the Ocean of Dreams or the Love-Sea.

Mahapralaya/Pralaya/Sea of Brahma

See: Cycle of Creation and the World Ages

Mahapralaya or the Sea of Brahma is the great dissolution of Creation at the end of a Yuga cycle.[257] The Void from which everything emerged was Pralaya who predates all things in existence, even the Creator whom DeMatteis regards as an aspect of God. Pralaya is referred as God's unconscious and the sleep into which everything, even God, must inevitably fall. Age after age, all of Creation is born from Pralaya and age after age it returns to nothingness.

Tiering: Mahapralaya/Pralaya is the Void of infinite nothingness that predates Creation and is the source from which all things emerged and will return, giving her High 1-A+ rating. She's the Cosmological apex representing the infinite unconscious of God making her the byproduct of what a Boundless being can produce.

The Divine Presence/The Smile/God

To understand the true nature of the Divine Presence or the Smile, we need to examine the concept of Brahman. In Hinduism, Brahman refers to the ultimate reality underlying all phenomena. Brahman is formless but is the birthplace of all forms in visible reality. In DeMatteis'[258] storylines[259] such a[260] concept was referenced multiple times.[258]

The Divine Presence shares a similar nature with the concept of Brahman. Its the Smile behind Creation and beyond Mahapralaya[241] featured in the 1988's Doctor Fate #6 story which, from its oneness, birthed duality and Chaos and Order exploded in an explosion of love that created a sea of love from which emerged whole worlds and universes. When the defunct souls' journey of discovery ends, they return to the Smile where they originate.

Like the concept of Brahman, the Divine Presence is the ultimate reality beyond everything from which all of existence originates. In DeMatteis' work, it's the Void Beyond All Voids, an infinite nothingness, the cosmic emptiness beyond space and time, form and thought and beyond the threshold of conscious limitations. It contains and surpasses everything and everyone in Creation. All gods are thoughts that exist in the mind of God.

Tiering: The Divine Presence is 0, as it transcends all of Creation and Pralaya infinitely, holding them as mere parts of its dream. God is non-dual as it exists beyond all intrinsic opposites, also as a changeless and eternal Void beyond all voids existing beyond the threshold of consciousness. Being the thing behind, beyond, within all things acting as an indivisible, immutable, and source for all of Creation.

Vertigo's Cosmology

Neil Gaiman and Mike Carey focus on folklore and the mystical aspects of the cosmology. Although Vertigo tends to be more consistent than DC, there are still some inconsistencies across storylines, such as the events of Lucifer's Rebellion. The cosmology of Vertigo is primarily based on the dreams and beliefs of humanity. Even the Presence was shaped by dreams, but Dream of the Endless remains inferior to the Presence and the Archangels, whose creation was only possible through other Night and Father Time, as they predate all versions of Creation that have been changed by dreams, and are the source of the reality-altering powers of dreams and beliefs.

Creation Origins

The Presence created the world. Then he created Michael and Lucifer. Michael's Demiurgic power gave birth to the first matter and Lucifer's will shaped it into the cosmos. Prior to the beginning was the night, without boundaries or end. Then came the beginning of time, which made the the Universe possible.[262]

Dreams, Beliefs, and Stories Defining Creation

Because it is the nature of Dreams, and ONLY of Dreams, to define Reality. Destiny is bound to existence. Death is limited by what she will or will not accept.

Now, the above sentence illustrates the nature of Vertigo's cosmology. Creation is malleable, and humankind's dreams, beliefs, and stories can change reality from beginning to end and create the deities they worship.[266][267]

This concept was first introduced in The Sandman: A Dream of a Thousand Cats, where it is said that cats were originally the dominant species on Earth, giant beasts that hunted humans. However, mankind's collective dream of a world where humans ruled over cats altered reality from its very beginning, making it so that humans were always larger than cats.[268] This explains the statement made by the Presence that he was shaped by external forces, apparently intended to be the beliefs and imaginations of humanity,[269] rather than a 4th Wall reference to the writers or real-world humans.

These beliefs and dreams altered the world atemporally -- all of time history forwards and back was altered. From that perspective, the Presence has always been God, superior to the Endless.

The Presence's Creation

The Presence's creation is often referred to as a universe. However, In this context, Universe refers to "the totality of Creation." This is shown by Desire's statement[272] and the location of the City of the Stars.[262] In reality, when we see Mister E take Tim Hunter through time to a possible future, we are told that there are infinite timelines.[273] Moreover, the Endless are described as mere consequences of the Presence's creation existing. All realms in the Presence’s Creation are intrinsically “real above real” such as the City of Stars and thus are completely ontological level of existence above the material.

Tiering

As the Presence's creation contains the domains of the Endless, as separate but encompassed extensions of realms that exist within his creation. Also, the Presence domain contains infinite timelines, dimensions, and realms, the material world is often regarded as the debased level of Creation. All feats involving the entire structure are High 1-A.

Heaven, Silver City and Hell

The Silver City predates and transcends Creation[274] and looks down upon it, holding the Tower of Unendingly High which contains the Logos, and is the birthplace of Will and Contemplation. It has been explicitly said that the Silver City is not part of the created order of things.[275]

Most of Gaiman's works use Heaven and the Silver City interchangeably.[276] However, it has been said that the Silver City is not paradise or Heaven[275] which may have been figurative.

Hell is the opposite of Heaven, and is its reflection.

Tiering

The Silver City/Heaven and Hell are High 1-A. Realms such as these are described to be beyond physical measure as such concepts are deemed useless there. Heaven predates Creation and the Silver City, a part of Heaven, sees the Universe below it as glistens and glitters of stars and nebulae like that of a child’s toy. Each soul harbors millions of Heaven and the afterlife contains the likes of the Mansions of Silence.

The Endless

The Endless are the anthropomorphic embodiments of powerful natural forces. They see each other as family, referring to each other as siblings, and they are the children of Mother Night and Father Time. The Endless are humanoid manifestations of the primal truths that constitute every aspect of the Presence's creation.

From oldest to youngest they are: Destiny, Death, Dream, Destruction, Desire, Despair, and Delirium (previously known as Delight).

The Ancient Rules

The Endless are limited by certain rules for their lives, which they must follow for the good order of the universe. One such rule is that if you spill family blood harm will happen to you as well, seen after Morpheus kills his son (Orpheus) which ultimately leads to Morpheus' own death, which is also why Dream said he wouldn't hurt Desire even if he really wanted to. Another rule is not to fall in love with mortals, because nothing good can come out of such a union, the most famous case being that of Kai'ckul and Nada. Morpheus has fallen in love with mortals on several occasions, but all ended in misfortune.

Dream of the Endless and the Dreaming

Dream is the third oldest of the Endless and is the anthropomorphic embodiment of the concept of dreams, stories and all that is not reality. He is both the lord and the incarnation of the Dreaming, the place where all dreams reside and where all dreamers go when they are asleep. Dream has multiple incarnations of himself[282] with the first being Dream of the Lovecraftian Horrors.

There are places in the Dreaming where the most important stories are stored: Creation stories, changing these stories not only change the Dreaming, but all of Creation.

Dream himself is the primal manifestation of this concept, but he has never demonstrated an ability to willfully alter the beliefs of mankind, thus he does not scale to the full power of belief and dreams.

The Dreaming contains stories that any mind can create whether they're dreaming of it or within the realm itself. There's an endless hierarchy of stories and dreams that layer themselves creating unreal worlds and it can reshape the world to have them as possible worlds.[290] That everything in the dream and those layers are dream within dreams[291].

Death of the Endless

Death is the second oldest of the Endless, and embodies the concept of death. Since life and death are counterparts, Death also has powers over life. She visits everyone twice, first when they are born and then when they die. Death does not only claim the life of living beings, she's also the death of ideas and concepts. Unlike other Endless, Death isn't bounded by rules and she doesn't need permission to travel to realms of other Endless.[292] She is regarded as the most powerful of the Endless.

Destiny of the Endless

Destiny is the oldest of the Endless. He was born even before creation began. In fact, he was tracking the Word in his book before it was spoken aloud. His book does not have a separate existence, it is tied to Destiny and can never be stolen. Even Michael Demiurgos couldn't take the Book of Destiny from him. The Book of Destiny was given to him by Father Time. Destiny's realm is the Garden of Forking Ways, the maze-like paths of which he walks continually.

The Script/Book of Destiny

Destiny carries the Book of Destiny which contains a record of all that was, all that is, and all that will be.

The Book of Destiny is based on the script of reality. Destiny is the side-effect of the Presence predetermining Creation. He's not a side-effect of Creation itself, but a side effect of the act of the Presence creating a plan for Creation to follow. The Book of Destiny only contains the Presence's creation. Lucifer's Creation, which is a totally separate cosmos, is beyond Destiny's influence. This was shown when the Basanos, who draw their power from the Book of Destiny said that they're losing their power in Lucifer's creation.

Tiering

  • All Endless: Delirium, Despair, Desire, Destruction are High 1-A. The Endless are the primal truths of the Presence's creation and oversees every aspect of it. Dream's oldest incarnation exists outside of space and time and is a part of the eldritch abominations that exists in space beneath space and space beyond space. The Dreaming also see all aspects of its itself as tiny facet including the hierarchies of stories, unreal worlds, and all the lands within it.

The Basanos

The Basanos was a living deck of tarot cards created by the angel Meleos after Destiny allowed him to examine his book. The Basanos was meant to mimic Destiny's book. They are the lenses through which all infinite possibilities of Creation are focused. They are considered potential threats even for Archangels.[296] They foresaw their encounter with Lucifer and with the help of Izanami, weaved a great magic that caused Lucifer's own flames to consume him.[297]

Tiering

The Basanos are High 1-A. As seen above, the Basanos are meant to mimic Destiny's book and the lenses through which all infinite possibilities of Creation are focused. They are a considerable threat to the likes of the Archangels and can harm Lucifer.

Council of the First Circle

When all was void, when no Creation had yet been made, the Council of the First Circle set down the rules for what would be allowed. One of the members of the Council, Glory, is referred to as Shekinah, which is the "Glory of the Divine Presence". This makes it extremely likely that the Council of the First Circle are aspects of God.

Tiering

The Council of the First Circle are High 1-A. They predate the Presence's creation and made the its laws and the rules which the Endless follow and Glory and was unaffected when reality, The Endless and Destiny's Book was rewritten by the dreams and imaginations of a thousand dreamers.

Mother Night, and Father Time

Mother Night and Father Time

Night and Time are the parents of Endless, and it is their interplay that made all versions of the Universe possible. Remember that in Vertigo, Universe means all of Creation. Therefore, "all versions of the Universe" did not refer to alternate realities, but to other versions of Creation that were changed by dreams as they predate this concept.


Tiering

  • Night and Time are High 1-A. They predate all versions of Creation that were changed by dreams, their interplay is what made all versions of Creation possible, and they are the source of the reality-changing power of dreams which can retroactively change Creation and create gods, including the Presence. Night is in a place of untime and unspace beyond all events horizon where she lacks any concepts: dreams, light, information. Time is the primal motion that pushed Creation into coming, as he gave Destiny his book, and sees all of Creation as one single continuum as he existed beyond the change of Creation before and after Morpheus fixed it.
  • Death, Destiny, and Dream are High 1-A. Death scales to Destiny who scales to the Basanos. Dream having a truer form that isn’t bound to Creation.

Mansions of Silence

Little is known about the realm called the Mansions of Silence other than that it is supposedly beyond Death's reach, houses all the rejected Creations, is not "real", is far beyond Heaven, and is where Lucifer consigned Tsuki-yomi after killing him, preventing him from passing into non-existence like other dead Gods. The Mansions and the rejected Creations within were destroyed by Lucifer.

Tiering

The Mansions of Silence are High 1-A. The realm beyond conventional Heaven and located in the eastern border in which the world and metaphysical plane meet called “Armeggdeon Plain.” This structure contains mirrors of illusions that were once Creations of the Presence and its multiplicity of infinity.

The Presence and the Archangels

The Presence

The Presence, sometimes referred as Yahweh, is the God of the Covenant and father to all Angels, with the main two being Michael and Lucifer. He's vastly superior to the Archangels and can unmake them as easily he created them. He has defined every variable, every physical law. Everything happens because he made them happen.

The Presence created the Universe then he created Michael and Lucifer who represents an aspect of their father. Michael inherited God's power from which he created the first matter and Lucifer, inheriting God's will, shaped it into everything. Destiny has been implied to be the personification and the side-effect of Yahweh's deterministic approach on Creation[294] with his book being based on the script written by the Presence.[295] The Presence has aspects like The Word, created when the Presence first spoke, whose existence was traced by Destiny in his book even before it was spoken aloud.

At first glance, the Presence appears as the supreme being of Vertigo. The reality is more nuanced.

It was strongly implied that The Presence only created one version of Creation and he isn't the only maker, there will be other makers, like Silk Man who wasn't created by Yahweh and comes from a much earlier Creation than the current one.[305] Furthermore, The Presence isn't a constant of Creation like the Endless are because the Jin En Moks, beings who were stated to exist even before the Presence himself, said that there were other Creators before and after the Presence.

Archangels

There are six Archangels: Uriel, who rules the worlds. Raphael, who oversees humanity. Michael, who is set over chaos. Saraquael, who is set over spirits. Gabriel, who is lord of the Cherubim and Seraphim. And Raguel, to whom has been entrusted the vengeance of the Lord.

Tiering

  • The Presence/Yahweh is High 1-A. He is the creator of Creation and all higher realms such as Heaven and Hell. He created all the Archangels and can easily destroy them and he defined every variable, the physical rules with his own will. Everything happens because he makes it happen. There's a rub since it was revealed that everything shown through what we see of Yahweh, is simply a manifestation of an aspect from a truer being. This is why Yahweh told Lucifer in an analogy that all things even the Void are part of his greater being and goes on to describe himself as “infinite and eternal” the same description used by Lucifer to describe the “Void.” Dreams gave faith and substances to this changeless and formless being, that permeates all things in the Void as simply a piece of him even when Lucifer metaphorically jumps across the Universe into the Void to create a Creation, the Presence will still work there. So while, Yahweh is High 1-A, due to the possibility of just being the simple emanation of a greater being that scales to the Void and possibly surpasses it will warrant possibly two layers into High 1-A for surpassing Creation and the Archangels.
  • The Demiurgic Archangels such as Michael and Lucifer are High 1-A. They scale to Heaven which transcends the Creation. Lucifer is far more powerful than Dream of the Endless. Space-time is an extension of the mind of Will which Lucifer embodies, and he destroyed Logos with a touch which is the first word which sung all of existence into being. It was stated that Elaine should push the "absence of space" of the Void in order create a new cosmos which should mean that she can affect the Void. Elaine with Demiurgic powers scales to Michael and Michael scales to Lucifer.

The Void

The Void is the endless, beginningless expanse of nothingness from which Creations rise and fall. Only the demiurgic powers bestowed by God could create new cosmos in the Void[309] and in order to create her own cosmos, Elaine first have to push the "absence of space" of the Void in order to fill it.[306]

It's important to note that were three Creations in the Void, those of the Presence, Lucifer and Elaine Belloc,[265] which were later combined by Elaine when she replaced the Presence. Since time has no real meaning in the Void, all Creations’ exist simultaneously, as seen when Lucifer flew into the Void with different versions of himself. This is why Lucifer said that in the Void it does not matter whether the Silk Man comes from a Creation before or after that of the Presence.

There are beings from an earlier Creation who survived the destruction of their universe such as the Jin En Moks who come from a reality older than the current Creation. One of them was Cestis who is much older than the Presence.

Tiering

The Void is High 1-A+ as it is beyond space-time and the hierarchy of dimensions and transcends it completely. Encompassing and surpassing the totality of Creation, Night, Time, and all Creation not filling even a portion of its infinity as they amount to 0 to a portion they can fill up. Completely transcends all levels of Creation and all the ones as insignificant things that fill and teem the Void with life. It is also the an aspect of God embodying the eternal canvas from which all things come, in other words, his mind.

The Unknowable

While the reality of who is supreme in the Vertigo Universe is always in question as seen above in the previous section with Yahweh and the Archangels. While this is true there are somethings to not overlook about the nature of God and where he fits in within the cosmology. While Yahweh isn't supreme outside his Creation as seen by the fact the Jin En Moks came from outside his influence, this refers only to the aspect of God shaped by humanity. This is explained to Lucifer that the aspect through which he acts is simply a lesser emanation of something, that Yahweh is simply a lesser aspect of God made to commute with his creations.[310]This is evident with the story that Yahweh told his son, Lucifer. The story by the Chinese philosopher Wu-Cheng’En of the Buddha and the Monkey King. See the Monkey King is trying to challenge Buddha to get the notion that he could escape the Buddha and will do something not even he could predict. So he jumps to the edge of the Universe and imprinted his will on the pillars that hold the sky, yet when he jumped back into the Universe and asked Buddha, if he could do that. Buddha simply lifted his fingers showing that the pillars were just parts of his being. In context, this is to explaining that Lucifer tried to espace God’s grasp by jumping into the Void but he paradoxically never left his will[310].

So who really is behind the mask “Yahweh” and how does it connect to the Void, and more so the “Unknowable?”

Well, its explained rather dubiously within the story. You see in Sandman: Overture we see that the Monks of Klaa believed that the Universe is simply a distraction in the mind of God when trying to reach enlightenment ideas and things drift across the Void.[262] This explains that God thoughts is Creation itself and his mind, the Void. This explains well that Yahweh’s true form or his actual shape is the Void, this was hinted all throughout the final issue of Lucifer even describing both Yahweh and the Void as “infinite and eternal.”[310] That’s where the Unknowable comes in, the true supreme and ineffable being in the Sandman Universe.

The Unknowable is the highest force and the reason for the existence of everything and exists in the timeless nothing before anything. He also surpasses all levels of Creation and any form of duality as well.[313]

Tiering

The Unknowbale, God, or Monad as you can refer to is the supreme perfect essence and the oneness behind all of Creation. Existing above all dualities and any extensions including the hierarchies of stories and all the possible worlds. He is the Godhead that emanated Creation with his aspects and transcends all of Creation as nothing but a mere thought meant to wash away with each idea he brings washing away into the Void which is nothing but his mind. So the Unknowable is 0 and the supreme being of the Sandman Universe.

Why Divide the Different Cosmologies?

Over the years, there has been a great deal of controversy regarding the statistics and power scaling of DC's cosmic entities. This is due to the various changes, continuity errors, and different interpretations of them that have been written by various authors over the years. This problem was compounded by statements from Jim Lee and Dan Didio that everything is canon. The problem we have been running into is that different writers often write independently of each other, adding new concepts to the older ones while ignoring or only somewhat acknowledging the works of the other writers. This is not always the case, as some writers pay considerable attention to the works of certain other authors, but even then there are some degrees of independence.

Regardless, the above circumstances cause the following problems:

  • Chain-scaling causing incongruent ratings: If characters are allowed to derive their statistics from complicated chains of powerscaling based on various distinct iterations of the cosmology never written to work with each other, they inevitably amass ratings conflicting with many of their storylines by scaling to disconnected scans. Through scaling across different versions of the cosmology, they end up with tiers incongruent with their true power level as written. For example, under a composite cosmology, many of DC's cosmic entities would be rated extremely high into Tier 1 despite never demonstrating a power level that high in any of their stories.

References

  1. 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 Justice League Vol 4 #22 (2019)
  2. Justice League Vol 4 #25, August 2019
  3. JLA Vol 1 #31, July 1999
  4. 4.0 4.1 Justice League Vol 4 #30, October 2019
  5. 5.0 5.1 Superman: The Man of Steel Vol 1 #115, August 2001
  6. Action Comics Vol 1 #782, October 2001
  7. Action Comics Vol 2 #15, February 2013
  8. Justice League Vol 4 #19, May 2019
  9. Final Crisis Vol 1 #5, December 2008
  10. The Multiversity #1
  11. Vampire Batman, Hypnotic Induction, And God: Grant Morrison Talks ‘the Multiversity’ [interview]
  12. The Multiversity Guidebook Vol 1 #1 March, 2015
  13. The Multiversity: The Deluxe Edition (2015)
  14. www.dccomics.com/characters/earth-33
  15. The Multiversity Vol 1 #2, June 2015
  16. 16.0 16.1 16.2 16.3 Final Crisis: Superman Beyond Vol 1 #2, March 2009
  17. Justice League Annual Vol 4 #1
  18. Final Crisis Vol 1 #5
  19. Final Crisis Vol 1 #7
  20. Doomsday Clock Vol 1 #10, July 2019
  21. Doomsday Clock Vol 1 #12, February 2020
  22. JLA Vol 1 #31, July 1999
  23. 23.0 23.1 23.2 Dark Nights: Metal Vol 1 #1, October 2017
  24. Justice League Vol 4 #27, September 2019
  25. Dark Knights Rising: The Wild Hunt Vol 1
  26. Dark Crisis on Infinite Earths: The Dark Army Vol 1 #1
  27. Justice League Vol 4 #27, September 2019
  28. Justice League Vol 4 #27, September 2019
  29. Justice League Vol 2 #44
  30. Dark Nights: Metal Vol 1 #6
  31. Dark Nights: Metal Vol 1 #6
  32. Captain Atom Vol 3 0
  33. The Hellblazer Vol 1 3
  34. The Flash Vol 6 7
  35. 35.0 35.1 The Flash Vol 6 #14, December 2024
  36. 36.0 36.1 36.2 36.3 36.4 36.5 Final Crisis: Superman Beyond #1, October 2008
  37. Grant Morrison interview regarding Final Crisis
  38. The Green Lantern Vol 1 12
  39. Dark Knights Rising: The Wild Hunt Vol 1 #1
  40. The DC Book: Vast and Vibrant Multiverse Simply Explained, November 2021
  41. Batman/Superman: World’s Finest Vol 1 #23, March 2024
  42. Lazarus Planet: We Once Were Gods Vol 1 #1, March 2023
  43. Batman Vol 3 #134, June 2023
  44. Batman Vol 1 #680
  45. Justice League Vol #19
  46. 46.0 46.1 Batman/Superman Vol 2 #22, November 2021
  47. 47.0 47.1 Action Comics Vol 1 #1000, June 2018
  48. 48.0 48.1 48.2 JLA Vol 1 #28, April 1999
  49. Justice League Vol 4 #19
  50. Justice League Vol 4 #19
  51. 51.0 51.1 JLA Vol 1 #29, May 1999
  52. The Multiversity Vol 1 #1
  53. Justice League Incarnate Vol 1 #1
  54. Justice League Vol 4 #19
  55. Final Crisis: Superman Beyond Vol 1 #1
  56. Justice League Vol 4 #20
  57. 57.0 57.1 The Multiversity Guidebook Vol 1 #1 March, 2015
  58. The Multiversity Vol 1 #1, October 2014
  59. The Multiversity: Thunderworld Adventures
  60. Doomsday Clock Vol 1 #12
  61. The Multiversity Guidebook Vol 1 #1
  62. Infinite Frontier Vol 1 6
  63. Justice League Incarnate Vol 1 #5
  64. Final Crisis Vol 1 #6, January 2009
  65. The Multiversity Guidebook Vol 1 #1
  66. The Flash Vol 5 #49
  67. Booster Gold Vol 2 #1, October 2007
  68. Booster Gold: Futures End Vol 1 #1, November 2014
  69. The Flash Vol 1 #796, June 2023
  70. Action Comics Vol 1 #984, September 2017
  71. Batman/Santa Claus Vol 1 #4, February 2024
  72. 72.0 72.1 JLA Vol 1 #12, November 1997
  73. The Multiversity Guidebook Vol 1 #1, March 2015
  74. JLA Vol 1 #36, December 1999
  75. Arion, Lord of Atlantis Vol 1 #1, November 1982
  76. Superman Vol 6 #14, July 2024
  77. 77.0 77.1 Animal Man Vol 1 #14, August 1989
  78. 78.0 78.1 Animal Man Vol 1 #19, January 1990
  79. -Animal Man Vol 1 #15, September 1989
  80. 80.0 80.1 80.2 Animal Man Vol 1 #6, December 1988
  81. Animal Man Vol 1 #25, July 1990
  82. Animal Man Vol 1 #12, June 1989
  83. Animal Man Vol 1 #23, May 1990
  84. Animal Man Vol 1 #22, April 1990
  85. Justice League Dark Vol 2 #23
  86. Animal Man Vol 1 #18, December 1989
  87. 87.0 87.1 87.2 87.3 87.4 87.5 Animal Man Vol 1 #49, July 1992
  88. Animal Man Vol 1 #50, August 1992
  89. Animal Man Vol 1 #73, July 1994
  90. Hellblazer Vol 1 #193, April 2004
  91. Swamp Thing Vol 5 #12, October 2012
  92. 92.0 92.1 Animal Man Vol 1 #55, January 1993
  93. Animal Man Vol 1 #84, June 1995
  94. 94.0 94.1 Animal Man Vol 1 #85, July 1995
  95. Swamp Thing Vol 2 #48, May 1986
  96. 96.0 96.1 96.2 Animal Man Vol 1 #80, February 1995
  97. Are you afraid of Darkseid Vol 1 #1, October 2021
  98. Animal Man Vol 2 #18, May 2013
  99. 99.0 99.1 Animal Man Vol 1 #50, August 1992
  100. Animal Man Vol 1 #87, September 1995
  101. Animal Man Vol 1 #86, August 1995
  102. Animal Man Vol 1 #81, March 1995
  103. Animal Man Vol 1 #89, November 1995
  104. 104.0 104.1 104.2 Swamp Thing Vol 2 #171, October 1996
  105. Final Crisis: Secret Files, February 2009
  106. Justice League Odyssey Vol 1 #24, November, 2020
  107. Batman Vol 1 #702, October 2010
  108. 108.0 108.1 108.2 Justice League Dark and Wonder Woman: Witching Hour Vol 1 #1, December 2018
  109. Doom Patrol Vol 2 #53
  110. Justice League America Vol 1 #73, April 1993
  111. JLA Vol 1 #6, June 1997
  112. JLA Vol 1 #30, June 1999
  113. DC One Million Vol 1 #1, November 1998
  114. Animal Man Vol 1 #5
  115. 115.0 115.1 Justice League Dark Vol 2 #10, June 2019
  116. Justice League Dark Vol 2 #6, February 2019
  117. Justice League Dark Vol 2 #5, January 2019
  118. The Multiversity Guidebook Vol 1 #1, March 2015
  119. Batman: The Return of Bruce Wayne Vol 1 #6, December 2010
  120. Batman Vol 1 #702
  121. Justice League Incarnate Vol 1 #1
  122. Justice League Dark Vol 2 #5, January 2019
  123. Inside the Mind of Grant Morrison
  124. Final Crisis Vol 1 #7, March 2009
  125. Wonder Woman Vol 5 #53, October 2018
  126. Final Crisis Vol 1 #3
  127. 127.0 127.1 Infinite Frontier Vol 1 #0, May 2021
  128. 128.0 128.1 Animal Man Vol 1 #83, May 1995
  129. JLA: Paradise Lost Vol 1 #1, January 1998
  130. Genesis Vol 1 #1, October 1997
  131. Jack Kirby’s Fourth World Vol 1 #2
  132. Jack Kirby’s Fourth World Vol 1 #18, August 1998
  133. Justice League Dark Vol 2 #15, November 2019
  134. Wonder Woman Vol 5 #57, December 2018
  135. Dark Nights Death Metal: Rise of a New God Vol 1 #1
  136. Justice League Dark and Wonder Woman: The Witching Hour, December 2018
  137. Justice League Dark Vol 2 #28
  138. Justice League Dark Vol 2 #10
  139. Wonder Woman Vol 5 #53, October 2018
  140. Final Crisis: Superman Beyond Vol 1 #1
  141. Final Crisis: Superman Beyond Vol 1 #1
  142. Final Crisis: Superman Beyond Vol 1 #1
  143. Final Crisis: Superman Beyond Vol 1 #1
  144. 144.0 144.1 The Multiversity Vol 1 #1, October 2014
  145. Inside the Mind of Grant Morrison
  146. Final Crisis: Superman Beyond Vol 1 #2
  147. Newsarama Interview Pt. 1
  148. Newsarama Interview Pt. 1
  149. Multiversity Turns the DC Universe Into a Quantum-Theory Freakfest
  150. Final Crisis: Superman Beyond Vol 1 #2
  151. [1]Inside the Mind of Grant Morrison]
  152. Final Crisis: Superman Beyond Vol 1 #2, March 2009
  153. Final Crisis: Superman Beyond Vol 1 #2, March 2009
  154. Final Crisis Vol 1 #7, March 2009
  155. Final Crisis Vol 1 #1, July 2008
  156. Dark Nights: Metal Vol 1 #3, December 2017
  157. 157.0 157.1 Flash Forward Vol 1 #1, November 2019
  158. Year of the Villain: Hell Arisen Vol 1 #1, February 2020
  159. Justice League Dark Volume 2 TPB - 1st printing "Lords of Order!" Justice League Dark (2018) #8-12 and ANNUAL #1, 2019
  160. Justice League Dark and Wonder Woman: The Witching Hour, December 2018
  161. Justice League Dark Vol 2 #3, November 2018
  162. Dark Nights: Death Metal Vol 1 #7
  163. Dark Crisis on Infinite Earths Vol 1 #4
  164. Flashpoint Beyond Vol 1 #5
  165. Flashpoint Beyond Vol 1 #5
  166. Flashpoint Beyond Vol 1 #1
  167. The Multiversity Guidebook Vol 1 #1 March, 2015
  168. Justice League Vol 3 #33, January 2018
  169. Wonder Woman Vol 5 #53
  170. Sideways Vol 1 #5, August 2018
  171. Justice League Vol 4 #30, October 2019
  172. The Multiversity Guidebook Vol 1 #1 March, 2015
  173. Justice League Vol 4 #34
  174. 174.0 174.1 174.2 Batman: The Return of Bruce Wayne Vol 1 #2, July 2010
  175. Justice League Vol 4 #19
  176. Heroes Initiative - Scott Snyder (Orig. archived 4/29/20)
  177. Countdown Vol 1 #39, August 2007
  178. 178.0 178.1 Justice League Annual Vol 4 #1, March 2019
  179. Death of the New Gods Vol 1 #7, May 2008
  180. Final Crisis: Secret Files, February 2009
  181. Grant Morrison: Final Crisis Exit Interview, Part 2
  182. Grant Morrison on Final Crisis #1
  183. Justice League Annual Vol 4 #1, March 2019
  184. 184.0 184.1 Justice League Vol 4 #20, May 2019
  185. Dark Nights: Death Metal Rise of the New God, December 2020
  186. The Flash Vol 1 #760, October 2020
  187. The Flash Vol 1 #768, May 2021
  188. The Flash: Rebirth Vol 1 #4, September 2009
  189. 189.0 189.1 189.2 189.3 The Flash Vol 6 #13, November 2024
  190. 190.0 190.1 190.2 190.3 190.4 The Flash Vol 6 #11, September 2024
  191. 191.0 191.1 The Flash Vol 6 #15, January 2025
  192. 192.0 192.1 192.2 192.3 The Flash Vol 6 #12, October 2024
  193. Dark Nights Death Metal: Rise of the New God Vol 1 #1
  194. Infinite Frontier Vol 1 #3
  195. Dark Nights: Death Metal Vol 1 #7
  196. Justice League Vol 4 #22
  197. 197.0 197.1 JusticeLeagueIncarnate1-4
  198. Dark Nights: Death Metal Vol 1 #1, August 2020
  199. Multiversity Guidebook Vol 1 #1
  200. Green Lantern Vol 6 #7, December 2021
  201. JLA Vol 1 #11, October 1997
  202. The Flash Vol 1 #798, July 2023
  203. Jack Kirby’s Fourth World Vol 1 #1, March 1997
  204. Genesis Vol 1 #4, October 1997
  205. Genesis Vol 1 #3, October 1997
  206. Justice League Incarnate Vol 1 #4
  207. Green Lantern Vol 6 8
  208. New Gods: Godhead Vol 1 #1
  209. Dark Crisis: The Deadly Green Vol 1 #1
  210. Dark Crisis: The Deadly Green Vol 1 #1
  211. Dark Crisis: The Deadly Green Vol 1 #1
  212. Animal Man Vol 1 #48, June 1992
  213. Animal Man Vol 1 #51, September 1992
  214. Swamp Thing Vol 2 75
  215. Phantom Stranger Vol 4 #5
  216. Trinity of Sins: Phantom Stranger Vol 1 #17
  217. Swamp Thing Vol 2 #166
  218. Swamp Thing Vol 2 #167
  219. Detective Comics Vol 1 #961, September 2017
  220. Swamp Thing Vol 2 #46, March 1986
  221. The Spectre Vol 2 #1, April 1987
  222. JLA Vol 1 #37, January 2000
  223. JLA Vol 1 #41, May 2000
  224. JLA Vol 1 #35, November 1999
  225. JLA: Paradise Lost Vol 1 #3, March 1998
  226. JLA Vol 1 #31, July 1999
  227. Wonder Woman Vol 2 #150, November 1999
  228. The Flash Vol 5 #11
  229. Blackest Night Vol 1 #7
  230. Swamp Thing Vol 2 75
  231. Moneky Prince Vol 1 #6, September 2022
  232. Trinity of Sins: Phantom Stranger Vol 1 #15, March 2014
  233. JLA Vol.1 #22, September 1998
  234. 234.0 234.1 Kid Eternity Vol 2 #3, November 1991
  235. Doom Patrol Vol 2 #26
  236. Doom Patrol Vol 2 #41, February 1991
  237. Doom Patrol Vol 2 #85, December 1994
  238. Doom Patrol Vol 2 #86, January 1995
  239. 239.0 239.1 239.2 239.3 239.4 239.5 Doctor Fate Vol 2 #3, January 1989
  240. Doctor Fate Vol 2 #20, August 1990
  241. 241.0 241.1 241.2 Doctor Fate Vol 2 #6, May 1989
  242. Doctor Fate Vol 2 #9, August 1989
  243. Spectre Vol 4 #15, May 2002
  244. 244.0 244.1 Spectre Vol 4 #20, October 2002
  245. Spectre Vol 4 #18, August 2002
  246. 246.0 246.1 Spectre Vol 4 #27, May 2003
  247. 247.0 247.1 247.2 Spectre Vol 4 #3, May 2001
  248. 248.0 248.1 248.2 Justice League Dark Vol 1 #39, April 2015
  249. Adventures of Superman Vol 1 #580, July 2000
  250. Justice League Dark Vol 1 #33, September 2014
  251. Larfleeze Vol 1 #5, January 2014
  252. 252.0 252.1 252.2 JLA/The Spectre: Soul War Vol 1 #2, February 2003
  253. JLA/The Spectre: Soul War Vol 1 #1, January 2003
  254. 254.0 254.1 254.2 Doctor Fate Vol 2 #17, May 1990
  255. 255.0 255.1 Doctor Fate Vol 2 #8, July 1989
  256. Trinity of Sin: The Phantom Stranger Vol 1 #11, October 2013
  257. Doctor Fate Vol 2 #10, September 1989
  258. 258.0 258.1 Justice League Dark Vol 1 #34, October 2014
  259. Justice League Dark Vol 1 #32, August 2014
  260. Justice League Dark Vol 1 #31, July 2014
  261. 261.0 261.1 The Spectre Vol 4 #10, December 2001
  262. 262.0 262.1 262.2 262.3 262.4 Sandman: Overture Vol 1 #4, February 2015
  263. Sandman Vol 2 #69, July 1995
  264. 264.0 264.1 Lucifer Vol 1 #26, Jule 2002
  265. 265.0 265.1 265.2 265.3 265.4 265.5 265.6 265.7 265.8 Lucifer Vol 1 #75, August 2006
  266. Tweet 1
  267. Tweet 2
  268. Sandman Vol 2 #18, August 1990
  269. Tweet 2
  270. Sandman Vol 2 #30 September, 1991
  271. Lucifer Vol 1 #73, June 2006
  272. 272.0 272.1 272.2 272.3 272.4 Sandman: Overture Vol 1 #5, July 2015
  273. 273.0 273.1 The Books of Magic Vol 1 #4, March 1991
  274. 274.0 274.1 The Books of Magic Vol 1 #1, December 1990
  275. 275.0 275.1 275.2 275.3 Sandman Vol 2 #24, March 1991
  276. 276.0 276.1 276.2 Sandman Vol 2 #23, February 1991
  277. Lucifer Vol 1 #11, April 2001
  278. 278.0 278.1 Sandman Vol 2 #48, April 1993
  279. Sandman Vol 2 #71, September 1995
  280. DC Comics Encyclopedia: Updated and Expanded, 2008
  281. 281.0 281.1 Sandman: Overture Vol 1 #6, November 2015
  282. 282.0 282.1 282.2 Sandman: Overture Vol 1 #1, December 2013
  283. The Books of Magic Vol 1 #3, February 1991
  284. Names of Magic Vol 1 #2, March 2001
  285. Books of Magic Vol 1 #3, February 1991
  286. Sandman Vol 2 #2, February 1989
  287. 287.0 287.1 The Dreaming Vol 1 #3, August 1996
  288. The House of Mystery Vol 2 #39, September 2011
  289. Sandman Vol 2 #15, April 1990
  290. The House of Mystery Vol 2 #39, September 2011
  291. The Dreaming: Waking Hours Vol 1 #4, January 2021
  292. The Vertigo Encyclopedia, 2008
  293. Vertigo: Winter's Edge Vol 1 #2, January 1999
  294. 294.0 294.1 Lucifer Vol 1 #52, September 2004
  295. 295.0 295.1 Lucifer Vol 1 #51, August 2004
  296. Lucifer Vol 2 #12, January 2017
  297. 297.0 297.1 Lucifer Vol 1 #23, April 2002
  298. Lucifer Vol 1 #2, July 2000
  299. Lucifer Vol 1 #25, June 2002
  300. Sandman: Overture Vol 1 #2, May 2014
  301. 301.0 301.1 Lucifer Vol 1 #37, June 2003
  302. Lucifer Vol 1 #39, August 2003
  303. Lucifer Vol 1 #38, July 2003
  304. Lucifer Vol 1 #36, May 2003
  305. 100 Bullets Vol 1 #38, October 2002
  306. 306.0 306.1 Lucifer Vol 1 #57, February 2005
  307. Lucifer Vol 1 #53, October 2004
  308. Lucifer Vol 1 #20, January 2002
  309. 309.0 309.1 Lucifer Vol 1 #21, February 2002
  310. 310.0 310.1 310.2 Lucifer Vol 1 #75, August 2006
  311. The Dreaming Vol 2 #10, August 2019
  312. The Dreaming Vol 2 #20, June 2020
  313. Black Orchid Vol 2 #12, August 1994
  314. Doctor Fate Vol 2 #20, August 1990
  315. 315.0 315.1 Dark Nights: Death Metal Vol 1 #1, August 2020
  316. Justice League Vol 4 #26, August 2019
  317. Sandman Vol 2 #30, September 1991
  318. Justice League Dark and Wonder Woman: The Witching Hour, December 2018
  319. Justice League Annual Vol 4 #1, March 2019
  320. Lucifer Vol 1 #58, March 2005

Discussions

Discussion threads involving DC Comics Cosmology